Today’s case highlights the important role that all of the facts play in a court’s legal calculation and an important operational consideration for your agency: it is necessary to have a plan in place that allows officers to change and reevaluate the use of force throughout an incident. Especially in today’s age of video recording and all eyes on our officers, we must be […]
Qualified Immunity, Deadly Use of Force Continue Reading
Today’s article will discuss a case that focuses on an Officer-Involved-Shooting in Warren, Arkansas and deals with the shooting of a suspect who, unbeknownst to the officer, was not in possession of a handgun at the time he was shot. Under these circumstances was the officer entitled to Qualified Immunity? As we navigate through this difficult time, I know that I am preaching to the
Use of Force: Officer Involved Shooting – Goffin v. Ashcraft Continue Reading
For today’s article, we will look at a Civil case out of Massachusetts where the trial court and ultimately, the 1st Circuit, looked at the facts and circumstances involved in O’Brien’s arrest and subsequent booking and determined that the officers were entitled to Summary Judgment and dismissed the case. Prior to filing this civil claim O’Brien pled guilty to a number of criminal charges including assault
Civil Use of Force – O’Brien v Town of Bellingham Continue Reading
First Circuit United States v. Del-Rosario-Acosta, 968 F.3d 123 (1st Cir. 2020) Three Puerto Rico Police Department officers responded to a call from a gas station reporting an armed person on the premises. When the officers arrived, they encountered a crowd of people. After the officers ordered the crowd to disperse, they saw Rafael Del Rosario-Acosta (the defendant) walk to a nearby parked car. The defendant got
Circuit Court of Appeals – September 2020 Continue Reading
As we navigate through this difficult time, we know that one of our basic liability protections, qualified immunity, is under siege on all fronts, at both the state and federal levels (for more on Qualified Immunity see Parts One, Two, and Three from our three part Qualified Immunity Series). Interestingly, today’s case upholds the protections afforded by Qualified Immunity and comes from, of all places, the 9th Circuit!
Deadly Force Pursuit & Qualified Immunity: Monzon v. City of Murrieta Continue Reading
There are a lot of conversations across the globe today regarding UOF in the US. And one thing that we can all agree on is that police officers making a joke out of training, especially in the area of use of force, is not a good place to start. Today’s article focuses on a recent case, Wright vs. City of Euclid[i]. To start things off, here’s
What Not to Do: UOF Training 101 Continue Reading
Part Three – What the Public Needs to Know So, what is qualified immunity? What does it mean to society as a whole? And what should law enforcement officers tell the public when it comes to qualified immunity? What we really need to talk about is how qualified immunity affects our day to day operation. The difficulty as a lay person who watches news
Qualified Immunity – What Every Officer Needs To Know: Part Three Continue Reading
Part Two – The Law of Qualified Immunity and Due Process To fully understand qualified immunity, we need to discuss why qualified immunity is important to the judicial system and taxpayer dollars. More often than not as a Use of Force consultant the questions that I get asked are how do you protect yourself and your agency? And there’s three things that I always
Qualified Immunity – What Every Officer Needs To Know: Part Two Continue Reading
History of How Qualified Immunity Came to Be As I watch what is occurring across the Country I am confused. I have practiced law for nineteen years. And I’ve been in awe over the past couple of months as I have watched legislatures and individuals across the country have conversations about qualified immunity. Like most of my practitioners, we probably didn’t think too much
Qualified Immunity – What Every Officer Needs To Know: Part One Continue Reading
A case out of the 10th Circuit back in January 2020 started as a typical neighborly dispute. This case has a number of twists and turns involving Reasonable Suspicion vs Probable Cause, handcuffing during an Investigative Detention, and the process for releasing a suspect if a determination is made to release the handcuffed suspect without further detention. Before we begin, a couple of things should
Investigative Detention: Donahue v. Wihongi Continue Reading